By The Tanika O'Brien Group
We often get asked: does a newer home always sell for more? And is buying an older home a smart investment or a renovation risk? The truth is, the age of a home plays a meaningful role in how it’s valued—but not always in the way you might think. Here in Santa Rosa Beach and across the 30A corridor, we’ve seen buyers pay premiums for historic charm or walk away from brand-new builds with poor craftsmanship.
Understanding how home age connects to market value helps you make smarter decisions—whether you’re buying, selling, or improving a property. Let’s break it down.
Key Takeaways
-
Home age affects value, but location, maintenance, and design play major roles
-
Older homes can command high prices if they’re updated and well-maintained
-
Newer homes aren’t always better—quality and design matter more than age
-
Strategic updates can offset age-related value drops
What Home Age Really Means for Value
Most buyers associate newer homes with higher prices—but age alone doesn’t determine value. In fact, many homes built decades ago still outperform newer properties on price per square foot when other factors are in their favor.
Factors That Influence How Home Age Affects Market Value
-
Location matters most – A 1990s home in a top-tier coastal community often sells higher than a brand-new home inland
-
Maintenance history – Well-maintained older homes often have fewer issues than neglected new builds
-
Renovation level – A remodeled kitchen, new roof, or upgraded HVAC can add more value than a birth year ever could
-
Architectural appeal – Buyers often pay more for original craftsmanship, high ceilings, or classic layouts not found in newer builds
We’ve sold 20-year-old homes for more than nearby new construction—simply because the quality, condition, and location were unmatched.
The Appeal of Newer Homes
New homes offer clear advantages—especially for buyers looking for energy efficiency and lower short-term maintenance.
What Buyers Love About New Construction
-
Modern floor plans – Open layouts, larger closets, and bonus spaces designed for today's lifestyles
-
Energy efficiency – Better insulation, new windows, and high-efficiency systems that lower utility costs
-
Updated finishes – No need for immediate upgrades to flooring, counters, or fixtures
-
Builder warranties – Protection against structural or systems issues in the early years
In high-demand areas like Santa Rosa Beach, new construction also tends to attract buyers who want turnkey living or plan to use the home as a short-term rental.
Why Older Homes Still Compete—and Sometimes Win
Many older homes are built with better materials and craftsmanship than what’s standard in new builds. And in mature neighborhoods, lot size, character, and location often carry more weight than age.
How Older Homes Hold or Increase Value
-
Established neighborhoods – Tree-lined streets, walkability, and larger lots boost appeal
-
Architectural charm – Original features like wood beams, vaulted ceilings, or arched entryways attract premium buyers
-
Room to renovate – Investors and end-users alike see value in customizing older homes to meet their style
-
Strong structure – Homes built before the era of mass production often used higher-quality materials
We've helped buyers fall in love with 30-year-old properties because the design and location offered more than any nearby new home could.
How to Protect or Boost Value in an Aging Home
If you're selling an older home, age doesn't have to work against you. Strategic upgrades and preventative care can keep it competitive.
Smart Ways to Offset Age-Related Depreciation
-
Update key systems – Replace or service HVAC, roof, plumbing, and electrical if they’re more than 10–15 years old
-
Modernize kitchens and baths – Buyers care most about these areas and will often overlook age if they feel updated
-
Boost energy efficiency – New windows, insulation, and appliances go a long way
-
Enhance curb appeal – Fresh paint, landscaping, and lighting can make a home feel newer from the start
We always recommend sellers invest in a pre-listing home inspection if the property is older than 20 years—it builds buyer trust and speeds up closing.
How Appraisers Consider Age
Appraisers do consider the age of a home—but not in isolation. They compare it to similar properties in the same area, adjusting based on condition, improvements, and features.
What Appraisers Look For Beyond Age
-
Effective age – A well-updated 1985 home might have an “effective age” of 10–15 years
-
Comparables – Value is based on what similar aged homes have recently sold for nearby
-
Functional obsolescence – Outdated layouts, small closets, or awkward room flow may reduce appraised value
-
Deferred maintenance – Older homes with visible issues (like roof leaks or failing HVAC) will appraise lower
A home’s actual construction date is only one part of the puzzle—presentation and upgrades matter just as much.
FAQs
Should I buy a newer home for better resale value?
Not necessarily. Resale value depends on location, quality, and upkeep more than age. Some older homes in great neighborhoods appreciate faster than newer builds.
What upgrades matter most in older homes?
Focus on kitchens, bathrooms, windows, and major systems. These updates improve buyer confidence and reduce price objections.
How do I price my home if it’s 20+ years old?
We’ll look at recent sales of similar-aged homes in your neighborhood, then adjust based on your updates, condition, and location. A well-maintained older home often outperforms expectations.
Contact Us Today at The Tanika O'Brien Group
Whether you're buying or selling, understanding how home age influences market value is key to making smart real estate decisions. We help clients all across Santa Rosa Beach navigate these factors every day—whether it's pricing a decades-old gem or finding new construction that truly holds its value.
Reach out to us, The Tanika O'Brien Group, and we’ll help you evaluate your property with expert insight. From market trends to remodeling guidance, we’re here to make sure you move forward with clarity and confidence.
Reach out to us, The Tanika O'Brien Group, and we’ll help you evaluate your property with expert insight. From market trends to remodeling guidance, we’re here to make sure you move forward with clarity and confidence.
